• 0 Posts
  • 262 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 15th, 2023

help-circle


  • You think satellite launches are maintenance free and cheap, or is this some sort of long form of sarcasm?

    Of course satellites aren’t free to launch/maintain/replace, but for the solution of globally accessible high speed internet its much cheaper than using exclusively physical links.

    Brother, we don’t need gaming latency in deserts and the antarctic…

    Who is the authority on where we need what specific internet performance? I don’t think anyone would argue high speed internet access is central to economic prosperity and to reap the benefits of modern technology in society. Without technologies that enables this to nearly everyone we’re on our way to creating a split society of “haves” and “have nots”. Most of those I’m seeing here arguing against global high speed internet access are very comfortable “haves” pulling up the ladder behind them. I’m not saying satellite is the only way but right now its looking the cheapest and fastest to implement. I’m absolutely open to ideas that skip satellite internet that provide the same benefit for equal cost, but I’m not seeing any of that.




  • Building out and maintaining fiber to all remote users in the entire world would be astronomically expensive! Probably more expensive than the all of the top one hundred most expensive works projects in the world combined just to build it out. Then the huge cost of maintaining it.

    The longest distance you can run a piece of fiber without a repeater is 100km max. So your suggestion means installing hundreds of thousands of fiber repeaters in some of the most remote place on Earth. Keep in mind, what you’re suggesting would have us running fiber to Antarctica too.

    Who is paying for all of that one-time and ongoing costs?



  • You’re either extremely disingenuous or exhibiting really poor reading comprehension that you’re interpreting what they’re suggesting as “zero satellites”.

    I’m asking good faith questions. I refuse to strawman @dohpaz42@lemmy.world and put words in their mouth. However, their responses are pretty vague and I’m trying to get clarity on their position.

    Starlink currently has 9800+ satellites, which is 1.6x that 6000 figure you cited. For one single company.

    From my understanding of their position even 1 is too many.

    As to continuing with you on the topic, given you’ve only allowed your two options for your reading of my questions and both of those barbs, I don’t have any faith that we’d have a pleasant or useful conversation, so I’ll end ours here while we’re still bordering on friendly.







  • The Breakfast Club was a 1985 movie depiction of teen rebellion for GenX teens written and directed by John Hughes where the teens act out against the rules and are smarter than the adults around them.

    Not to be confused with “Ferris Bueller’s Day Off” which was a 1986 movie depiction of teen rebellion for GenX teens written and directed by John Hughes where the teens act out against the rules and are smarter than the adults around them.

    I prefer the latter to the former.







  • it’s already enshittified with many customers reporting consistently double the ping and half the download speeds from their original experience.

    I don’t think that is an example of enshitification in this case. In the technical world there are measurements for this call SLAs (Service Level Agreements). This means that if you pay for a specific service with contractually delivered performance. The service needs to deliver at least that level of performance, or you are entitled to refunds/credits/resitution for the service provider not meeting their obligations.

    Now, just because a service provider is required to deliver a minimum of service, they can (and frequently do) provide even better service than they are obligated to. This is pretty typical of technology services where a new platform is being built out and there is lots of spare capacity as users are just being onboarded. I have no doubt that there were Starlink users that got fantastic performance when only a fraction of the network was in use by others. If this is their baseline, then from their perspective, they are getting less than they did before. If the performance still meets what was sold to them contractually, then they’re still getting what they paid for they’re just not getting a whole bunch more they never paid for.

    It’s not the idea of a truly globally accessible internet that makes it worthless, it is the fact it is being done by a for-profit publicly-traded company owned by a trillionaire. Any one of those three things would mean the product is guaranteed to get worse eventually, all three mean it is guaranteed to get worse as quickly as possible.

    That’s … a pretty questionable definition of “objectively worthless” then. By that definition all products or services from non-government owned companies would meet that definition of “objectively worthless”. I’m confident that moves the definition from “objectively worthless” to “subjectively worthless”.

    You’re very welcome to hold that opinion, but I think the majority of its subscribers would disagree with you.