<a rel="me" href="https://layer8.space/@helix">Mastodon</a>

  • 1 Post
  • 162 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 27th, 2024

help-circle













  • I covered all the usual bases liberals use when declaring China isn’t socialist.

    But I’m neither a liberal nor declaring China isn’t doing some kind of socialism. It’s not a socialism I personally like but that’s my preference, I prefer the so called concordance democracy over a party system in general. The only country I know who are doing this often is Switzerland, but they have other issues (like high cost of living and xenophobia/lack of diversity).






  • You made the unbacked claim of “Chinese imperialism.” The onus is on you to prove it.

    I read all my comments again and no, I didn’t. At least I can’t see where I did. I simply disagreed with your definition of imperialism and noted that the definition I disagree with would fit China aswell. I’m of the opinion neither the EU nor Germany nor China are purely imperialist in my understanding of the word, apart from the aspects I already stated. This is basically an appeal to purity by myself, but I know I’m being pedantic and that’s fine with me.

    I never claimed the US wasn’t imperialist, or that China was imperialist, I just disagreed with your initial claim Germany is participating directly in imperialism, while they aren’t, in my opinion. If your opinion differs, that’s fine, but stop trying to misrepresent my actual arguments. 🙄

    If we’re going by the burden of proof laying on the initial commenter: the onus is on you to prove what you said initially.


  • China is in the developing stages of socialism.

    Let’s hope for the best! Currently it looks like there’s a single party system devoid of meaningful opposition and capitalism is running rampant as long as it serves the party’s interests, but maybe they’ll eventually become a real democracy.

    Inevitably, this will lead to de-globalisation and I think this can be a good thing, as long as the world powers including China finally do something about climate change and other man-made horrors.

    Thanks for all of the links, you did great work and provided interesting food for thought. I looked at some of them and choose to not engage further with this. I don’t really understand where you’re coming from as you refuted points I didn’t even make – like equating the existence of billionaires with the absence of socialism and similarly, conflating outsourcing as the single criterion for imperialism.

    I disagree but you have nice graphs, I hope China keeps developing into the right direction.