I think we are playing a very long hide and seek game with torrent being so reliant on trackers and web indexers/communities, they close some, others pop up, and the users are dispersed, and younger generations never learn how to pirate. In the long run we are losing.
I think we really need a fully peer-to-peer search mechanism, integrated to torrent client, and despite the difficulties, I think it is possible to have something that is permissionless, yet safe, based on a distributed, Sybil resistant, reputation system.
I think tribler search feature is a good start, but its tor-like privacy features makes it too slow, preventing its widespread adoption (and given the search is basically trusting the peers, it would be overwhelmed with garbage if it became mainstream).


Usenet doesn’t have these issues. Everything stays available. It’s older than torrents yet safer and still much better. Loads of communities, I can find and download everything, while not having to upload any data or be dependant on seeders. I don’t understand why people use torrents. As soon as I learned about usenet I switched, after years and years of torrenting, and I never looked back.